< Return to Table Of Contents | Next >



AB 319, the Safer Baby Products bill, would eliminate two dangerous types of chemicals found in baby products.

Two pieces of legislation to protect the health of Californians from toxic chemicals were introduced by California Asm. Wilma Chan (Oakland), chair of the Assembly Health Committee. Both sponsored by Environment California, AB 319 would eliminate two types of toxic chemicals in children’s toys and baby bottles, and AB 289 would require chemical manufacturers to provide the state with more information on the industrial chemicals they use.

Removing dangerous chemicals from children’s toys
AB 319, the Safer Baby Products bill, would eliminate two dangerous types of chemicals found in baby products. The chemicals, phthalates and bisphenol-A, are widely used in children’s feeding products and toys and there are no laws or regulations prohibiting their use in the U.S.

Toxics advocates Yana Kucher and Teri Olle began researching the problem last year while working on “Growing Up Toxic,” a report highlighting the effects of toxic chemicals on the sensitive processes of fetal and infant development. They began working to craft a policy solution with Asm. Chan, who has a history of leadership on public health issues.

Both types of chemicals are potent endocrine disruptors — chemicals that can interfere with the proper functioning of hormones in our bodies, potentially causing irreparable damage during the processes of fetal and infant development. Phthalates, often used in soft PVC plastic children’s toys, have been linked in lab studies to reproductive birth defects, premature birth and asthma.

Even at very low doses, Bisphenol-A, a common ingredient in hard plastic baby bottles, has been linked to obesity, Down’s syndrome and reproductive impairments such as reduced sperm production and endometriosis.

If enacted, California would become the first state in the country to ban the chemicals. The European Union and at least 12 countries have passed bans or restrictions on the use of phthalates in products for small children.

“Many parents would be shocked to learn that the plastic baby bottle they’re giving their child could damage their child’s health. When you look at the science behind these chemicals, there is no question that they ought to be banned from baby products,” said Chan.

“Our children’s health is nothing to play with,” said Yana Kucher, environmental health advocate for Environment California. “The emerging science is clear. These chemicals leach out of plastic bottles and toys. They have been linked with all manner of diseases and disturbing trends, including obesity and early onset of puberty. Are we willing to sacrifice the health of future generations for a softer rubber ducky or harder plastic bottle? The answer must be no.”

Finding a better way to detect toxic chemicals
While AB 319 deals with eliminating several specific chemical threats to childhood development, the California Chemical Information Act, Assembly Bill 289, gives state agencies critical information on thousands of chemicals that are used in the state.

AB 289, co-sponsored by California Communities Against Toxics, will require manufacturers to provide the state with analytical methods for detecting their chemicals as they make their way into the air, water, soil and the human body.

According to voluntary reporting, over 52 million pounds of chemicals are released into the environment in California every year. However, state scientists often lack the tools to detect which chemicals are ending up where. The state has no means of detecting over 75 percent of the chemicals that enter our environment.

“The issue of PBDEs — the toxic flame retardants building up in many California women’s bodies and breast milk — provided a prime example of what can happen when we don’t have the tools we need to identify chemicals,” said Asm. Chan, who authored the 2003 legislation to ban toxic flame retardants. “By the time we learned of the problem, thousands of women had already been exposed. This measure will require chemical companies to provide us with the information we need to detect their chemicals, before they can put their chemicals on the market. This bill could save the state millions of dollars and the health of thousands of residents.”

Because the chemical industry is not required to supply the state with this information, state labs must develdevelop and verify analytical methods for chemicals falling under their jurisdiction. The cost of developing analytical methods from scratch can run up to $1 million for a single chemical, placing a significant financial burden onto state agencies, and, by extension, onto California taxpayers. However, this process should be much easier and less expensive for chemical manufacturers, who designed the chemical and therefore should know how to detect it.

“Looking for chemicals in our air and water can be like looking for a needle in a haystack,” said Kucher. “We know that certain chemicals are being released into the air we breathe and the water we drink, but without knowing how to find them, we don’t know how much of a danger they pose to the environment or human health.”

Both bills are due to be heard in Assembly committees this spring.

Alternatives are available


Some major manufacturers of
toys and baby products in the U.S. have restricted the use of phthalates as a result of growing concern over the last few years. A recent Environment California survey of toy manufacturers showed that out of 26 companies, 6 do not use phthalates at all in new products, and 12 do not use phthalates in products intended to be put in the mouth of “small” children (usually under 3 years of age). Even though some toy manufacturers choose not to use phthalates in products intended for small children, there are still many products on the market that do contain phthalates, and there is no California or U.S. law requiring the chemicals’ phase-out.

Companies that say they have stopped using phthalates in children’s products (partial list):

- Brio

- Evenflo

- First Years

- Gerber

- Megabloks/Ritvik

-Safety 1st


MEMBER ACTION:
Sign up for e-mail issue alerts



Environment California

3435 Wilshire Blvd. #385 • Los Angeles, CA 90010 • (213) 251-3688

Contact Us Privacy Policy